Right to Housing
Manos Tsangaris and Anh-Linh Ngo in conversation with Arno Brandlhuber
“We have enough space,” says Arno Brandlhuber. The problem is who has access to it. In our interview, he explains why housing should be made a legally enforceable right, why vacant offices can be part of the solution to the housing crisis and why architecture must end its fixation with new construction.
Interview
The title of this Akademie-Brief is Obdach – shelter. The word denotes something more elementary than housing: a roof over your head, a place where you can stay and withdraw to. What is the minimum a space must offer for a person to be able to live there? Is there such a thing as an architectural minimum for housing?
Interestingly enough, that question was answered in principle in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR). The covenant was adopted in 1966 and ratified by the Federal Republic of Germany in 1973; it entered into force in 1976. In Article 11, the parties to the covenant recognise the right to an adequate standard of living, including adequate food, clothing and housing.
What constitutes adequate housing was laid out in detail in 1991 by a UN expert committee. People must be able to rely on not losing their home arbitrarily. Housing must be affordable without jeopardising other basic needs. The home must provide shelter from cold, heat, rain and health risks. Drinking water, sanitation and energy must be available. Additional factors include accessibility, location in relation to work, schools and healthcare, as well as the cultural congruence of the building style and housing type.
This amounts to a comprehensive programme. Much of what we’re discussing today has been part of it for decades.
Taking all these criteria together, Article 11 can also be read as a spatial expression of human dignity. Although the Basic Law does protect human dignity and the inviolability of the home, there is no right to have a home in the first place. You are currently involved with the European Citizens’ Initiative “Right to Housing! Now and Forever”, which is campaigning to enshrine housing as a fundamental right at European level.
By ratifying the UN covenant, Germany has committed itself under international law to implementing the right to adequate housing. In 2023 Germany also acceded to the covenant’s Optional Protocol. Since then, individuals who believe their rights under the covenant to have been violated have been able to file a complaint with the relevant UN committee. But that doesn’t mean you can lay claim to a home in a German court.
The German Institute for Human Rights has repeatedly drawn attention to this gap. There is now a National Action Plan with the goal of ending homelessness by 2030. But a goal is not a law. We must therefore close this gap and enshrine the right to housing in law.
Why are you taking the European route with “Right to Housing! Now and Forever”? Germany could translate this obligation into national law itself.
It could. But we citizens have no corresponding instrument to compel the federal government to do so. At European level, we have the European Citizens’ Initiative. If one million people from a sufficient number of member states support such an initiative, the European Commission must address it. With “Right to Housing!” we aren’t inventing a new right. The question is how to make it a right people can genuinely invoke.
Since the drafting of the covenant, new questions have emerged, especially as a result of the climate crisis. If energy-efficient renovation means that existing residents can no longer afford their homes, nothing has been gained. That is why we link the social and the ecological dimensions. Renovation, conversion and repurposing must receive far more funding than demolition and new construction.
But even an enforceable right does not create affordable housing. Land, property and capital markets each follow their own logic. What happens when the laws of the market collide with legal entitlements?
That’s where it gets interesting. An enforceable right to housing is on a collision course with the interests of the property industry and ultimately with capital accumulation. Property isn’t just somewhere people live; it’s also an investment product. And land is a special case, because no more of it can be created.
One can therefore also turn the question around: What would happen if everyone had a legal right to adequate housing? Such a claim would inevitably restrict private control over land and property.
While this demand might sound radical, our initiative takes a pragmatic line. We start from a simple premise: the flats have already been built, or the land required for them has already been built on. We have enough space. However, it often stands empty, is used for other purposes or is out of reach for many people.
What specific demands does the initiative make?
The right to housing! Now and Forever. Our three demands are as simple as they are concrete: use, invest, protect.
Use means actually using existing space for housing. Vacancies and short-term rentals must be regulated, vacant residential and office buildings must be brought back into use, and conversion and change of use must take priority over new construction.
There are currently around two million square metres of vacant office space in Berlin. That’s the equivalent of around 30,000 flats – which could not be built that fast.
Exactly. Office buildings, in particular, show how absurd the situation sometimes is. A building might be well suited to housing in spatial terms, but planning law often doesn’t allow for a change of use. Since the pandemic, a lot of office space is simply no longer needed in its previous form.
Then there is the accounting logic. An office building has a certain value that is recorded in the books of accounts. But that value has long since ceased to be realisable, whether through sale or rental. A change of use can mean the book value has to be revised downwards. When in doubt, owners may therefore prefer to leave the space empty – even though flats are urgently needed.
Invest means that the public sector needs to start investing directly again. Its investments, however, must not drive up land prices and property values but should aim to secure housing permanently as a common good. This is why we are also calling for a European housing fund.
And the third point is protect. If housing is affordable, it must remain so. A publicly funded renovation should not mean residents have to move out once it’s finished. So we propose a European housing agency to ensure greater transparency with respect to the housing stock.
You say we have enough space, but that raises a simple question: Why does homelessness exist then? We live in a wealthy society with a vast building stock, yet we accept that people have to sleep on the street. Why?
The fact that there is space does not necessarily mean that people have access to it. If people have to live on the street despite there being enough space, it’s obviously not a problem of quantity.
That’s why our initiative focuses on the legal entitlement. There is an obligation under international law, but no one can derive an actual claim to a home from it.
Without a place to live, everything else becomes difficult. Where do I sleep? Where do I keep my things? Where can I retreat to? Where do I organise my day-to-day life from? Without such a place, social participation quickly becomes abstract.
The recent election success of the Left Party in Berlin has shown that elections can be won on the issue of housing. The other parties have also incorporated affordable housing into their manifestos. Yet no broad political movement has emerged. One reason for this may be that social housing is still seen as something for people in need, even though around 60 per cent of Berlin households meet the income requirements for a housing eligibility certificate. Why don’t the middle classes see housing as their issue too?
You have to distinguish between policy and politics. At the policy level, almost everyone now says: Of course we need affordable housing. But when it comes to concrete implementation, larger issues of ownership, power and distribution come to the fore.
On the issue of housing, the boundary between the middle class and those in need no longer holds. Although many people who traditionally consider themselves middle class would actually be entitled to subsidised housing, they still perceive it as something for the socially disadvantaged, not for themselves.
Discussions about ownership and distribution quickly lead to the question of land. What role does that play in your initiative?
We deliberately didn’t make a fundamental reform of land law a prerequisite for our campaign. I see little political prospect for that at the moment. But even within the existing system, there is much that can be done.
Take a piece of farmland that is rezoned as building land on the basis of a political decision. The next day, that same parcel of land is worth many times more. Hans-Jochen Vogel repeatedly spoke of the “unearned increment”. The owner didn’t create this value; a public planning decision did. So why should the entire increase in value go to them?
With the European Citizens’ Initiative, you’re opting for an instrument of direct democracy. In Berlin’s 2021 referendum on transferring large housing companies to public ownership, 57.6 per cent of those who voted backed the proposal. To this day, the transfer to public ownership has not taken place. What does that do to instruments like this?
If you create these kinds of instruments but don’t treat the result as a political mandate, the political system and its actors end up with more than just a credibility problem – whether or not you agree with the result.
The sell-off of public properties in Berlin politicised me. As recently as ten or fifteen years ago, the Liegenschaftsfonds Berlin, the state’s property fund, was privatising land and buildings on a large scale on Berlin’s behalf. Initiatives such as “Stadt Neudenken” (Rethinking the city) and the “Runder Tisch Liegenschaftspolitik” (Round table on public property policy”) that followed it succeeded in changing that: as a rule, Berlin no longer sells its land and property but assigns it as a leasehold estate instead.
It’s a similar story with the housing stock. Since German reunification, large segments of public housing stock have been privatised. That was a historic mistake, one that the transfer to public ownership is now meant to correct.
One argument often raised against the socialisation of property is that it would cost billions without creating a single new home.
I think that’s a specious argument. Of course, a change of ownership doesn’t create a single new home in itself. But the money hasn’t just disappeared. Berlin gets housing in return, which translates into assets and rental income. No property company making an acquisition would simply ask: What will it cost me? It would also ask: What am I buying for that price, and what income and room for manoeuvre will it give me? The recent study by the Hans Böckler Foundation shows that the transfer is financially viable from the moment it takes place. It recommends that the six state-owned housing companies take over the housing stock.
The flats remain rented flats and become a permanent part of a public property policy. So the question is how much of its housing stock a city wants to control itself in order to actively shape its housing policy.
Let’s get back to the vacant offices. If they are to be converted into affordable, publicly subsidised housing, the criteria for social housing become relevant: room sizes, floor plans, standards of interior finish. In existing buildings, requirements like these can quickly become an obstacle. So do we also need to rethink our idea of what a flat has to be?
That’s exactly why the ICESCR criteria are interesting. They describe quite precisely what constitutes adequate housing, without prescribing what a flat should look like.
There’s nothing in them about the exact number of rooms a flat must have or how big it should be. Nor do they say that a flat has to fit the father-mother-child model. Which standards do we really need? And which have little to do with the quality of the housing?
Some standards follow a property-management logic that extends right down to the skirting boards. That’s hard enough to justify in new construction, but it becomes absurd when such standards mean that an existing building can no longer be used.
We need to work much more with what already exists. That’s often cheaper, and in terms of climate policy it makes more sense. The renovation rate in Germany is around 1 per cent. It would need to be significantly higher for us to meet our climate targets.
Brussels shows that conversion can also work on a larger scale. In 2021 and 2022 alone, conversions totalling nearly 300,000 square metres of office space were approved there. Approximately 70 per cent of that was for housing. In 2021, almost one quarter of all new housing in Brussels came from former office space.
That shows that conversion doesn’t have to be a niche strategy. It is relatively easy for the public sector to ensure that such repurposing projects are profitable by permitting changes of use and reorienting funding priorities. And I have no problem with an investor making money from it. Why would I? If vacant or unprofitable office buildings are converted into flats, and at least some of those are permanently secured as affordable rental housing, then both goals have been met.
If less new construction takes place and there is more preservation, conversion and further development, does managing what already exists become an architectural task in itself?
I’m convinced that it has to. For a long time, we architects were guided by the notion that we design a building, we build it, and then others take over.
I think that image of the profession is a thing of the past. Preserving, converting and continuing to develop buildings over long periods of time is becoming part of our work. Incidentally, that also means more commissions for architects, especially for smaller local practices. If we don’t understand that, we’ll eventually become the new coal miners. Then the production model an entire profession has settled into will simply disappear.
Are architects ultimately facing professional homelessness?
Yes, if you want to put it that way. We’ve made ourselves very comfortable in new construction. If that production model collapses, and we don’t learn to work with what already exists, we really will lose the roof over our professional heads. And yet it’s been right in front of us all along: the existing building stock.
Arno Brandlhuber is an architect and has been a member of the Architecture Section at the Akademie der Künste since 2016.